Avedon's other weblog
Saturday, January 15, 2011

The Centrist Duck Test

A year-and-a-half ago, some folks thought I was bizarre for saying that Obama is an ideological centrist.

I was told back then that I was a little weird for talking about all of this "New Democrat" and "Third Way" centrist stuff, and comparing Obama's policies all of the time to the DLC's "Progresive Policy Institute" think tank policy memos.

It was relayed to me that Obama was "basically a liberal," but working within the constraints of the system in Washington, which he was sure to navigate masterfully...if I just gave him time to win 85-dimensional chess, and I withheld criticism that might turn fellow liberal Democrats into impetuous and impatient children incapable of recognizing what was good for them.

I was assured that this was the "pragmatic" way forward, and that it would all work out for the best. I was admonished that Obama surely must be a "progressive," and that, if I didn't recognize his policies as liberalism, it was because A) the secret liberalism couldn't be let out yet, lest Joe Lieberman vote against cloture, B) it was what he had to do, in order to enact some great New Deal 2.0 later, or C) it was the "most liberal" policy that could be accomplished by anyone, ever. In some extreme cases, it was edgily theorized the problem was D) that I must harbor some racist tendencies (Tim Wise's "With Friends Like These, Who Needs Glenn Beck: Racism and White Privilege on the Liberal-Left" ) that caused my misunderstanding of Obama.

And, patiently, over and over again, I replied that, if it looked like a centrist, and it walked like a centrist, and it quacked like a centrist, and its policies were straight out of the DLC's think tank, and its messaging was straight out of the New Democrat Network, and its appointed bureaucrats were Clinton-ites and Rubin-ites, and if, after it was finally elected to power after an extended primary season campaigning for the votes of a liberal Democratic base, it actually said "I am a centrist"...

...then Obama is probably a centrist.

As I can see from the commentary on this thread rebutting Michael Crowley (formerly a columnist at Third Way rag "The New Republic"), I may not have to argue that point quite as hard anymore.


stuart_zechman (3:56 PM) permalink




archives:


Notes & Emergency Stuff from:
The Sideshow

Avedon's other weblog
HOME

Essentials:
Making Light
Atrios
Ruminate This
LiberalOasis
Talk Left
Nathan Newman

Friends' Weblogs:
Making Light
Amygdala
Pigs & Fishes
Christine Quinones
YAWL
Charlie Stross
Monkeys In My Pants
Macadamia
Pagan Prattle
As I Please

VLWC:
Atrios
Demosthenes
Rittenhouse Review
Maxspeak
Public Nuisance
Scoobie Davis
MadKane
Adam Magazine
Vaara

Loyal Opposition:
Jim Henley

Left-Right No War:
Stand Down

More Weblogs:
Matthew Yglesias
Looking Glass
Ted Barlow
Charles Kuffner
Ethel the Blog
Brad DeLong
BusyBusyBusy
Groupthink
Counterspin
Junius

Blah3
Cooped up
Oliver Willis
Body and Soul
Pandagon
War Liberal
The Scribbler
A Level Gaze
Nick Kessler
Nathan Newman

Ruminate This
Mr Happy
Chris Nelson
Greenehouse Effect
Uggabugga
Hullabaloo
The Watch
Skippy
Alas
Jack Cluth

Daily Brew blog
T.C. MITS
Terminus
William Burton
Get Donkey
AintNoBadDude
P.L.A.
BertramOnline
The Agora
Liberal Desert

TBogg
Naked Writing
Ignatz
Noosphere Blues
CalPundit
Anger Management
Seeing The Forest
Talking Dog
Woolgathering
The Agonist

GailOnline
Sisyphus Shrugged Interesting Times
Orcinus
Pontificator
Mark Kleiman
Skimble
Blue Streak
Kieran Healy
No More Mr. Nice Blog

Badattitudes Journal
Mike Finley
Testify!
Better Rhetor
Fanatical Apathy
Soundbitten
Late Night Thoughts
Liquid List

Specialists:
Talk Left
First Draft
Punditwatch
LiberalOasis
Daily Kos
Lefty Directory
Bloviator
Progressive Gold

Don't Drink & Read:
The Poor Man
Talking Points
Altercation
Conason
Tapped
Hightower

What's Left:
Bear Left
Lean Left
Stage Left

Metablog:
Me-Zine
Metastatic

Clickable:
Takebackthemedia
Consortium News
Daily Howler
MWO
Buzzflash
Smirking Chimp
Spinsanity
The Note
TomPaine
Daily Brew
Moose & Squirrel
Make Them Accountable
Failure is Impossible
Ampol
Summary Opinions
The Hamster
Cursor
Bartcop

The Comics:
Boondocks
Oliphant
Toles
Danziger
Auth
David Horsey

Newspapers:
WashPost
NY Times
Guardian
Telegraph

Resources:
Browse the Bible
US Constitution
Bill of Rights

Radio:
KEXP
Radio Paradise
WFMU
Grassy Hill
Mike Malloy
ieamerica
Liberal Resurgent
RadioLeft

Listen To:
Beck
Country Joe
Daniel Cainer
Dana Lyons
Flaming Lips
Kelley Hunt
Jason Mraz

Download:
Janis Ian
Lojo Russo
Sara Messenger
Barry Thomas Goldberg

Powered by Blogger